46th Annual General Meeting
October' 2011
 

Dear Members,

I feel honoured to welcome the members of the Association here at the 46th Annual General Meeting. At our AGM’S the Association has been portraying the profile of the sugar industry highlighting the main events during the year. I am pleased to present to you the review for the year 2010-11.

 
PRODUCTION 2010-11
The Year under Review

Though the devastating floods in July 2010 had severe affects on all crops, but sugarcane sustained the damages and turned out to be a higher yield crop being water intensive.
The plantation Area and the crop condition of the sugarcane (2010-11) promised high production in the beginning immediately after a deficit year. The devastating floods all over the country damaged most of the crops and the infrastructure in the country, but sugarcane crop was damaged the least, though flood losses on the sugarcane crop were estimated higher in the preliminary reports, yet the prolonged humid favourable weather and the satisfactory water supply helped well the growth of sugarcane crop.

Due to mixed estimates and expectations MINFA kept their estimate of sugar production to as low as 3.1 million tonne and insisted a deficit of about 700,000 tonne. PSMA had hard time in convincing the Government of Pakistan to hold the import of sugar till at least the end of February, when the production trend would be much clear. At the same time authorities resisted the import of raw sugar meant to supplement the production to save import of refined sugar.

After delaying the decision for import of refined sugar during crushing in progress, Government of Pakistan was informed that they might need not to import sugar as the production could exceed 3.9 million tonne. Due to the delay in relaxation of import duty on raw sugar only a small quantity of raw sugar was imported for refining. The pragmatic and realistic estimates of PSMA forced the policy makers to review deficits anticipated and we had total sugar production of 4.17 million tonne.

Total scenario of the year 2010-11 was thus as following:

 
Sugarcane Plantation  = 1,003,000     Hectors
Sugarcane Produced   54,480,400 Tonnes
Sugarcane Crushed
(With 81.7% utilization)
  44,511,571   Tonne
Sugar Produced from Cane   4,119,421   Tonne
Sugar Produced from Beet   13,535   Tonne
Sugar refined from Raw   39,629   Tonne
Total Sugar Produced   4,172,632     Tonne
Carryover Stocks
(Mills & TCP)
  1,033,003     Tonne
     
Availability for (2010-11)   5,205,635     Tonne
 
Thus the availability of sugar remained satisfactory till the end of the sugar year i-e 30th September 2011. The carryover stock is estimated at about                 1.1 mln. Tonne inclusive 0.2 mln. Tonne at TCP reserves, which should suffice comfortably for the month of October to December till the marketing of the fresh sugar from crushing campaign (2011-12) which is expected to be surplus. Diversion of sugarcane towards Gur making has been low in the year in comparison to past years.
 
Sugarcane & Sugar Price (2010-11)
Announced by the provincial Governments the support price of the sugarcane was Rs 127/- in Sindh and Rs 125/- in Punjab and KPK per 40 kg. As usual the growers were not happy with the announced price which is known as minimum support price i-e the actual procurement price could be anything higher than this. Availability of sugarcane when all the sugar mills start crushing at a time becomes highly competitive and the sale price to the mills generally reaches 50-60% higher than the support price as a result of stronger demand.
 The price of sugar always remain in lime light, which is an outcome of  sugarcane price  directly proportional to it, as sugarcane price  constitutes about 80% cost of production of sugar with further variations due to sucrose contents.
 
DOMESTIC AND INTERNATIONAL SUGAR PRICES 2010-11

Months

Domestic Sugar
Retail Price 
2010-11

International Sugar
Prices 2010-11

 

Rs. / KG

US $ Per tonne

Oct

81.91

682.97

Nov

87.98

719.41

Dec

73.78

747.52

Jan

72.65

770.36

Feb

67.02

746.21

Mar

66.95

701.88

Apr

67.14

655.56

May

65.77

599.94

Jun

69.19

688.47

Jul

70.74

769.50

Aug

74.65

736.20

Sep

76.03

694.41

Average 72.82  709.37
 
During February 2011, a request was made to the Government to procure at least 400,000 tonnes of sugar from Sugar Mills to enable them to clear outstanding of the growers. To decide the average production cost as desired by GOP, PSMA called in a meeting for this purpose on 13th May submitted the suggested procurement price as Rs 64/- per kg but the experts called from MINFA and Agricultural Prices Institute calculated production cost as Rs 54/- per kg. The difference being too high PSMA members were not in position to make an offer based on GOP working.
Ministry of Industries in one of their working papers recorded actual sugarcane prices as indicated by the provincial cane commissioners. In its working paper for sugar situation of 8th Feb 2011, Ministry of Industries indicated procurement price as Rs 167/- in Punjab, Rs 190/- in Sindh and Rs 203/- in KPK, Whereas to calculate the production price of sugar for purchase the original support price of Rs 125/-, Rs 127/- and Rs 125/- were used which were 33%, 50% and 62% lower than the procurement prices recorded by them. Naturally the production cost calculated thus was much lower than the actual cost and on these grounds the idea of providing relief to the growers and Millers was tactfully dropped.
TCP having tendered for the purchase of domestic sugar with Rs 60/- per kg as upper limits was shelved for no response and TCP was labelled for violation of rules of Competition Commission of Pakistan for fixing sugar price which was denied by them later. Ultimately the ECC rescinded its earlier decision of sugar purchase from PSMA member mills. 
 
Prospects 2011-12
Preliminary reports indicate an increase of 12% in the plantation area under sugarcane. The major increase being in Punjab has shown a rise from 672,200 Hectares to 754,700 Hectares promises an output of about 42.0 mln. Tonne, 80% utilization of which may yield about 3.2 mln. Tonne sugar. Hopefully we are moving towards Punjab’s best harvest 2011-12 surpassing 2007-08 production.
Similarly Sindh shows 15% increase in the sugarcane plantation area over the last year, but flood damages are yet to be ascertained as the flood water in few Southern Districts has not receded yet due to poor drainage. There is enormous damage in the cotton, paddy, sugarcane and vegetable fields. The additional sugarcane plantation may not yield positive effects balancing the flood losses, and the sugarcane production may remain closer to last year’s estimate of over         13.0 mln Tonne.
Crop prospects in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa are good. Any increase in the plantation area is not confirmed but sugar production is forecasted for at least 8% increase with a sugar production of about 282,000 tonnes. Thus total production of Pakistan for 2011-12 may hopefully exceed 4.7 mln. Tonne.
Sugarcane support price has already been announced as following for    2011-12 crops. Sindh Rs 154/-, Punjab & KPK Rs 150/- per 40 kg with an increase of 20%. Crop availability is expected as normal, farmers demand for higher price as usual will force the millers to a higher procurement cost.
It is a proven fact that sugar losses due to early start of crushing campaign is about 250,000 tonnes due to low recovery which is a national loss. A higher consumption of sugarcane in low recovery months causes short fall in higher recovery months forcing the end of campaign.
The following study prepared clearly indicates the production loss due to recovery %age and early end of crushing in the peak recovery period.
 
Periodic Recovery of sugar Mills in Punjab (Accumulated)

Years

Start Crushing

Nov' 15

Dec' 15

Jan' 15

Feb' 15

March' 15

April' 15

End Crushing

2002-03

15-20 Nov

         -  

6.97

7.71

8.06

8.29

8.47

15-25 Apr.

2003-04

15-30 Nov

         -  

7.5

8.37

8.72

8.94

9.09

05-25 Apr.

2004-05

1st Nov

6.88

7.87

8.41

8.67

8.91

8.96

15-30 March

2005-06

15-20 Nov

         -  

6.85

7.45

7.71

7.83

8.05

15-30 March

2006-07

15-30 Nov

         -  

7.32

7.84

8.08

8.24

8.5

10-15 Apr

2007-08

15-30 Nov

         -  

7.37

8.35

8.68

8.77

9.03

5-15 Apr

2008-09

15-30 Nov

         -  

7.46

8.59

9.00

9.47

           -  

5-10 March

2009-10

15 Nov-03 Dec

         -  

7.33 

8.33 

 8.79

8.88

-

5-10 March

2010-11

20-30 Nov

         -  

6.51

8.49

8.82

9.07

9.23

25-30 March

 

PSMA must convince the authorities with the negative affects of forcing these decisions. Once the price of sugarcane is based on sucrose content the growers will be attracted to sell their crop in time to fetch better price. PSMA is still looking for such modalities being discussed for the last ten years. We hope that a positive view of it will lead to progress, so as to put in place a proper recognized system to help the industry in shape to contribute to its full potential. 

Consumption in 2011-12 is projected to 4.40 million tonne. The consumption has been sluggish for the past two years due to higher prices of sugar. In short with the production estimated at 4.7 and the carryover stock about 1.1 mln. Tonne no import of sugar will be required in 2011-12. After the production situation is clear, there would be some surplus available for export and strategic reserves.

 

WORLD SUGAR SCENARIO
          Global sugar production 2011-12 is forecasted as surplus by about    4.0 mln.Tonne. It is widely suggested that despite a sizeable rise in the global production, the market will generally remain balanced and the world sugar market may face a fall from current world prices set to swing due to bumper crop.
There are expectations that global market may show a decline of at least    10-15% by early next year. ISO Estimate for 2011-12 is as under:
                   Production   : - 171.4 mln. Tonne
                   Consumption: - 168.1 mln. Tonne
World sugar stocks had contracted considerably in the last two seasons falling about 15 mln. Tonne thus the surplus production of 2011-12 may leave only about a million tonnes of surplus.

Brazil’s harvest (2011-12) that started mid April disappointed market expectations with cane and sugar production. The low yield and recovery has attributed to the multiple weather problems including a prolonged drought in the prime growing period and the recent prolonged frost affected severely the cane yield. It will take few years for the yield to fully recover as predicted by experts.
The cane and sugar production was revised downwards expecting lower output of sugar and ethanol as well. The downgraded forecast is now 30.6 mln. Tonne previously estimated at 32.8 mln. Tonne and fuel ethanol at 21.0 bln. Litres.

Indian sugar production is likely to rise 27.0 mln. Tonne compared to          24.6 mln. Tonne output 2010-11 continuing its upswing phase expecting 2011-12 harvest of about 360.0 mln. Tonne of sugarcane. World’s second largest sugar producer having received good monsoon combined with the recent good prices boosted the expected production in the forthcoming harvest. At the start of November 2011, sugarcane plantation stands at 5.14 mln hectares in comparison to the last year’s 4.9 mln. Hectares.
Indian export of sugar is expected to 4.0 mln. Tonne with consumption of over 23.0 mln. Tonne. Exporters are eager for export to take advantage of production delay in flood hit Thailand.

Thailand is expecting a bumper harvest of about 100 mln. Tonne which may achieve a record production of 10 mln. Tonne sugar. Thailand is the second largest sugar exporter in the world. It is now faced with worst floods in the half century which has inundated farms and is likely to delay crushing operation scheduled for mid November.

China’s purchases of sugar from the world market are expected to be on higher side. In recent months China imported about 1.2 mln. Tonne. A gap of about 2 mln. Tonne is foreseen in 2011-12. To make up for the depleted reserve stock and deficit in consumption, China’s import demand may rise to 2.75 million tonnes.

In European Union conditions for beet sugar are favourable against the weather conditions last year, thus expectations are for higher than 17.7 mln. Tonne i-e 13% higher than last year. Russian harvest is also progressing well expecting a record beet crop of about 40 mln. Tonne. 
At the conclusion of this review I would like to register my appreciation to the Zonal Chairmen the Central Executive Committee, the members and the Secretarial Staff for their continued co-operation. 

 
  Thank You  
31st Oct 2011   Javed A. Kayani
(Chairman)